For up-to-date information and comments, search the EE Community or start a new topic. |
03-08-2021 03:46 PM
Hi,
I have 4G Wifi at my house. All devices getting up to 40 Meg except my work laptop which goes through a VPN. Does anyone else on this forum work for or link to the NICS network through EE 4G Wifi?
EE saying there is 40 Meg to the house so its a VPN issue. My IT department are saying it is EE speed that is the issue. To add extra contradiction it seems to be OK when started, then fall off to less than a Meg during the day. If I disconnect from the VPN and reconnect, speeds go back up again for a while before dropping off again.
Anyone else having similar issues?
03-08-2021 04:29 PM - edited 03-08-2021 04:30 PM
@Fintan3 wrote:
EE saying there is 40 Meg to the house
To the house? Does that mean it's fixed BB over landline & not 4GEE at all?
03-08-2021 04:48 PM
No it is 4G. I have a dish on my house connected to a 4G router. Speed tests using Ookla speed checker is showing 30+ Meg and upto 40 Meg at times on other laptops and tablets and the Netflix speed checker is showing similar download speeds.
My work laptop, through the VPN is currently showing 19.59 Meg with a ping of 73. Earlier today it was 0.46 Meg. During the time of the slow speed on my work laptop the other devices were still getting full speeds.
There must be some conflict with my work VPN and EE 4G but neither side will agree it is there problem, hence I cannot get it sorted and am asking if anyone else has the same ISP and VPN.
03-08-2021 06:28 PM
Hi @Fintan3
I hope you're well and having a nice day, other than this issue of course.
The use of any VPN will slow your speeds down, this is due to the extra steps taken to encrypt your connection and send through a secure server.
Thanks
Chris
05-08-2021 02:44 PM
Hi Chris,
I agree you expect some reduction in speed but in my case the reduction is substantial. Getting 30+ Meg to other devices but as low as 0.4 Meg through the VPN.
The other issue is that this reduction is not all the time. When I first connect (or reconnect) I get normal speeds of 20ish Meg through the VPN but it then drops off with time.
05-08-2021 02:54 PM
Hi @Fintan3 ,
I think one test to throw light on the issue would be to connect two devices to your WiFi, one using the VPN and the second without using a VPN. When you notice slow-down using the VPN, you can simultaneously visit successively fast.com and speedtest.net on the other device to see whether your measured bandwidth is low or high.
I suspect your 4G LTE mobile broadband speed will remain relatively high. The fact that you notice a drop-off in speed via the VPN and them an immediate ramp-up on reconnection also suggests the effect is primarily related to the VPN and there is currently no evidence that the service provider's infrastructure is contributing (it might be contributing, there's just currently no evidence of that).
You could also try accessing the VPN via another route out to the internet, for example hotspotting from a mobile phone not on EE or borrow internet access from a neighbour for debugging.
05-08-2021 03:34 PM
Hi Mikeliuk,
Thanks for your response. My wife works from home connecting through our home BB (the same as me) but her employer does not use a VPN. She will spend hours on Zoom and WebEx conference calls with no problem. I have on occasion run the Ookla speed test on her laptop and again she is getting 30+ meg most of the time (sometimes it may drop off to 20ish Meg but still plenty good enough).
I have run various simultaneous tests over the past weeks and it appears that all other device's in the house are fine, except my work laptop (which I have also got replaced with a new probook).
The above would all point to the VPN. However, I have been on Zoom calls with colleagues, all of whom will be going through the same VPN (from their own home BB connections) and my connection is the only own with problems. Video drops out and audio is delayed. When I do a speed check it can be a low as 0.3 Meg.
Frustrating!!
05-08-2021 03:43 PM
Hi @Fintan3,
Has your wife been using Zoom when you have experienced the speed issues?
Are you able to run a speed test on your laptop when not connected to your VPN?
James
05-08-2021 03:55 PM
Hi @Fintan3 ,
It does sound like a fault or hiccup somewhere that your bandwidth over the VPN feels like it is being constricted over time. On balance, your VPN provider has the best chance of determining where the constriction lies as they can test everything after you first hit their servers using your internet access method.
The service provider is contracted to provide you with internet access and your wife's data/evidence suggests that is present and ok. The service provider is not out of the woods because you've reported that your colleagues are fine which perhaps marks you as an unlucky person.
A naïve hypothesis is that the VPN provider is not properly load-balancing VPN users between servers but the fact your colleagues are unaffected argues against this. Perhaps one play may be to access the VPN using another device but you may not have another significantly different device hanging around. One play could be to deliberately generate a low-level of traffic going via the VPN link to see if the constriction still occurs (the simplest would be to ping some public endpoint or maintain a fixed 1 Mbps upload).
I guess the best play is to coordinate with your VPN provider to monitor your traffic as you simultaneously carry out a large download or continuously run online bandwidth benchmarks to see where the traffic is being constricted (obviously at such time as you notice a constriction).